Skip to content
SEO Tools AI
SEO Tools AISign up

Comparison

Free backlink checker sites, side by side

A directory owner needs two things from a checker: a quick look at one tool, and a way to score the whole list. Few sites do both, so compare them on that.

SEO Tools AI research team ·

Four different wooden bridges standing side by side over a river for comparison

Four options, six questions

General positioning, written from public descriptions. Check each vendor's current terms before you build on any of them.
QuestionAhrefsMozMajesticOur API
Quick look at one domainFree checker pageLink Explorer, limited free useSite Explorer, limited free useFree domain and overview calls
Own score nameDomain RatingDomain AuthorityTrust Flow, Citation FlowDR, public formula
ScriptingAPI units inside a subscriptionAPI plans availableAPI plans availablePrepaid credit, from $0.10 per 1,000 calls
Bulk scoringBy planBy planBy plan2,000 domains per bulk_dr call
Keywords and rank trackingYes, a full suiteYesNot the focusNo
Data freshnessCrawled continuouslyVaries by productVaries by productRoughly monthly refresh

What the table does not say

Ahrefs sells API units inside subscriptions, from $129 a month for 200,000 units, with at least 50 units per request. That is fine for an agency. It is awkward for a directory that scores 3,000 domains once a month and then sits idle.

For keywords, rank tracking and a crawl that is fresh every day, Ahrefs or Semrush is the fuller product, and we say so plainly. Our API does one narrow job: link data at a low per-call price.

Two scores for the same domain will differ. That is normal. Each vendor measures its own graph, so pick one metric for the whole directory and keep it for every listing, otherwise your sort order mixes apples and pears.

What a free check costs in time

A free web form is built for a person with one domain in mind. The cost of using it for a list appears slowly, in hours you do not notice until the list is done.

Three patterns show up again and again among directory owners who try to stretch a free checker past its purpose.

Copy and paste stops scaling

At twenty rows a web form is an afternoon. At two hundred it becomes a job that never quite ends, and the first numbers you typed are older than the last ones.

Say you check one domain every two minutes. A list of 300 tools then takes ten hours of clicking, plus the time to paste each figure into the right cell. An API call for the same column takes seconds.

Scraping a form is fragile

Some owners write a script that submits a free form for them. It can break without warning when the page layout changes, and a site may refuse repeated requests after a few dozen tries.

A monthly sync cannot depend on a page its owner may change at any time. A documented endpoint with a stated price is a safer thing to build on.

When a free look is the right tool

A free checker earns its place when you are deciding whether a tool deserves a listing at all. One domain, one read, and a glance at the referring domains is all that question needs.

Use that look before you spend anything on a column. If the single result already contradicts your expectation, fix the expectation first, then decide whether the API is worth the set-up time.

A free look also shows you when a domain sits in the wrong category before you spend credit on it, which saves more time than most readers expect.

A checker is not a database

A web checker shows you a result and forgets it. Your directory needs the result stored next to the listing, with a date, so the next editor can see what changed.

If the checker has no export, you end up retyping the same figures every month. That is the point where a call that writes JSON into your own table pays for itself.

Keep the export in a format your sheet reads without a converter. A CSV or JSON file opens in almost any editor, and it outlasts a vendor's interface.

Do not blend scores

A column that shows Moz DA for some rows and DR for others is not a ranking. If you must cite another vendor, add it as a separate labelled column.

Pick a checker for a directory in four steps

01

Write down the question

Decide whether you need a single look at a domain or a score for every row. The answer removes most of the list before you read any vendor page.

02

Shortlist two or three

Keep the checkers whose free route covers your first test and whose paid route fits a monthly budget. Drop the rest without a second look.

03

Run the same five domains

Use the five-domain test from the section above on every shortlisted tool, and write the order of the results down in one plain note.

04

Commit to one metric

Pick the metric the directory will show and keep it for every listing. Adding a second metric later is a column change, while switching the whole sort is a rewrite.

Gardener inspecting five diverse plants of varying sizes to compare growth patterns

How to test a checker in ten minutes

Pick five domains you know well: a giant, a mid-sized SaaS, a niche tool, a brand-new site and your own. Run each through every checker you are considering.

Do not expect equal numbers. Look at the order instead. If all checkers put the giant first and the new site last, they agree on the shape, and the details are vendor noise.

Then look beyond the score. Referring domains and anchors are the parts a reader can verify, so a checker that hides them is asking for blind trust. See the glossary if a term is unfamiliar, and the sync recipe when you are ready to batch.

Wooden decision tree showing two branches leading to different tools for tasks

A short decision tree

If you list fewer than 50 tools, use any free checker by hand and skip the engineering.

If you list 50 to 300 and want a score on each, call bulk_dr from a spreadsheet script once a month.

If you also sell keyword research or rank tracking, you probably already pay for a suite, and the suite API may be enough for you.

If you run a comparison site with thousands of pages, the per-call price is what matters, so work out your monthly call count first. The budget walkthrough does exactly that.

Who should pick which checker

The right choice depends on the size of the list and on what you already pay for. Three common situations are worth a short look.

Read each one against your own list before you decide anything, because a plan that suits one owner can be a poor fit for the next.

A short list kept by hand

If you maintain a few dozen tools, a free checker and a spreadsheet are enough. Engineering an API sync only pays back once the same check runs again and again.

Keep the manual process honest with a fixed day each month. A ritual is what keeps a small list current.

An agency that already pays for a suite

An agency with a full suite may find the suite's own API covers its needs. Look at the units and the minimum per request before you assume the cheapest route is the one with the lowest sticker price.

Ahrefs, for example, sells API units inside a subscription, with at least 50 units per request. For a large client roster that can be the right deal, and for a small directory it usually is not.

A directory that shows one number only

Some owners want a single badge per listing and nothing else. That is the easiest case to get right, because the badge carries the vendor's name and the date, and nothing else competes for the reader's attention.

Even then, keep a second field in your own table with the raw value. If the badge later needs a different metric, you can recompute it without a second round of calls.

Choose the badge label with care. Write the vendor's name in full, and avoid short forms a reader could mistake for a different metric.

A comparison site with thousands of pages

Here the per-call price matters most. Count your calls for a month, multiply by the credit cost of each action, and compare the total with the subscription you were quoted.

Remember that a bulk call covers up to 2,000 domains. A large site may need only a few calls for the whole score column, which changes the arithmetic completely.

Before a comparison page goes live

  • Name the metric and the company that produces it.
  • Show the date each score was fetched, next to the score.
  • Link to a description of the method, not only to the number.
  • Say which domains were missing from the index and what the page shows for them.
  • Keep paid rows labelled and sort them apart from the organic list.

Checker questions

Which backlink checker sites are really free?

Several offer a limited free lookup, usually one domain at a time with capped rows. That suits a single check. Our domain, overview, stats and suggest actions are free with no key, but heavier actions use credits from your balance.

Can I use two checkers for the same listing?

You can, as long as each stays in its own labelled column. Showing both a DR and a DA invites readers to cross-check, which is healthy. Mixing them in one sort order is the mistake to avoid.